- Available 24/7: (312) 560-7100 Tap Here to Call Us
Can Snow, Ice, or Rain Help Your DUI Defense in Illinois?
DUI Arrests in Chicago Happen Year-Round—Even When Roads Are Dangerous
Driving in Chicago during the winter or early spring months comes with serious hazards. Between lake effect snow, freezing rain, black ice, and potholes hidden beneath slush, traffic violations become far more common—even for careful drivers. Unfortunately, many of those traffic stops lead to DUI arrests, especially when officers assume that bad driving equals impairment.
As a Chicago DUI lawyer, I frequently defend individuals who were arrested for DUI during bad weather. Many of them were never drunk. Their driving was affected by the same snow, sleet, or fog that thousands of other drivers were dealing with. But law enforcement saw a skid, a missed stop sign, or a slow response at a yellow light and assumed intoxication.
Illinois law does not require prosecutors to prove your intent—only that you were driving under the influence. But if weather conditions explain your driving behavior more plausibly than impairment does, it creates doubt. And in the criminal courts of Cook County, doubt is a powerful defense.
Understanding how to use weather evidence in your defense is not automatic. It requires strategy, preparation, and a lawyer who knows how to turn overlooked details into courtroom leverage.
The Law: Illinois DUI Charges and What Weather Can and Cannot Do
DUI charges in Illinois are governed by 625 ILCS 5/11-501. The law defines DUI as driving or being in actual physical control of a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol, intoxicating compounds, or any other substance that impairs your ability to operate the vehicle safely. The law also includes per se violations for having a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.08 or more.
A first-time DUI is a Class A misdemeanor, which can carry up to 364 days in jail, $2,500 in fines, mandatory substance abuse classes, license suspension, and the installation of a Breath Alcohol Ignition Interlock Device (BAIID)if you’re granted driving relief.
A DUI becomes a felony—an Aggravated DUI—if you have previous DUI convictions, were driving on a suspended license, had a child in the car, or caused bodily harm.
Weather conditions will not prevent a charge. But they may provide a defense against conviction, especially when the evidence the state relies on is ambiguous or subjective.
For example, field sobriety tests—such as the walk-and-turn or one-leg stand—become far less reliable when conducted on icy pavement or during a downpour. If your poor performance can be attributed to the elements, that undermines the prosecution’s claim of impairment.
Fictional Case Example: DUI Arrest in Albany Park During a Lake Effect Storm
Imagine a scenario in Albany Park, near Lawrence and Kimball. A woman is driving home from work in a snowstorm. The snowplows haven’t reached her side street. As she turns left, her car slides through a stop sign and she overcorrects, briefly crossing into the oncoming lane. A Chicago police officer happens to be nearby and initiates a traffic stop.
The officer notes that her speech is “slow and quiet,” her eyes are “bloodshot,” and she “fumbles” for her license. He asks her to step out of the car and perform field sobriety tests on a patchy, frozen sidewalk. She tries her best but struggles with balance.
She refuses the breath test, knowing her BAC is likely below the limit but not trusting the device. She’s arrested and charged with DUI based on the officer’s observations.
As her Chicago criminal defense lawyer, I take several steps:
I subpoena the dashcam and bodycam footage, which confirms the roads are snowy and the sidewalk is icy. I obtain weather reports from the National Weather Service and news footage showing deteriorating road conditions that night. I bring in a former traffic engineer to testify about street grading and plow patterns in the neighborhood.
We argue in court that her driving errors were caused by weather, that her “fumbled” speech was due to freezing temperatures, and that the field tests were invalid given the dangerous surface conditions. The judge finds the officer lacked probable cause to believe she was impaired—and the case is dismissed before trial.
How DUI Investigations Work in Illinois and Where Weather Fits In
Every DUI investigation in Illinois follows a similar progression:
An officer initiates a traffic stop based on observed driving behavior—such as swerving, speeding, or ignoring traffic signals. These actions are often misinterpreted during bad weather, where even skilled drivers make mistakes.
Next, the officer interacts with the driver and looks for signs of intoxication. This includes the smell of alcohol, slurred speech, glassy eyes, and unsteady movements. All of these can be caused by exposure to cold, exhaustion, or stress from dangerous driving conditions.
The officer then administers field sobriety tests, which are not mandatory and are often affected by weather. Poor lighting, uneven or icy pavement, snow accumulation, and high winds can all undermine test performance.
A preliminary breath test (PBT) may be offered roadside, but only the later evidentiary breath test taken at the station is admissible in court. Breath test results are affected by mouth alcohol, medical conditions, and improper calibration.
Finally, the officer makes the arrest, books the driver, and files a report. From there, your criminal case begins, and every piece of evidence must be examined.
This is where weather becomes crucial. A strong defense focuses not only on your behavior but on the conditions in which that behavior occurred. Your attorney must request camera footage, obtain street maintenance logs, gather weather alerts, and demonstrate that your driving and demeanor were consistent with a sober person navigating hazardous conditions—not an impaired driver.
Legal Defenses in DUI Cases Where Weather Is a Factor
Weather is rarely the only defense in a DUI case—but it’s often an essential piece of a broader strategy. Some of the most effective defenses include:
Showing that poor driving was due to icy or wet roads, not intoxication
Arguing that field sobriety tests were invalid due to environmental hazards
Challenging the validity of the traffic stop based on non-criminal driving in bad weather
Introducing video or expert testimony showing the road was unplowed or unsafe
Establishing that physical appearance symptoms were consistent with cold exposure, not alcohol
Using medical records to show alternative explanations for observed behavior
Raising constitutional violations, such as unlawful search, lack of Miranda warnings, or absence of probable cause
The stronger your documentation—photos, weather data, video, and witnesses—the better chance your Chicago DUI defense lawyer has of persuading the prosecutor or the judge that your case should be reduced or dismissed.
FAQs – DUI Defenses Based on Weather in Chicago, IL
Can icy roads explain swerving or poor control during a DUI stop?
Yes. If your driving was affected by weather rather than intoxication, your defense lawyer can present this as a valid alternative explanation in court. It may cast doubt on the officer’s conclusions.
Will the judge or jury believe that weather caused my behavior, not alcohol?
If the defense presents credible evidence—such as weather reports, photos, or expert testimony—yes. Many DUI cases in Chicago are reduced or dismissed when strong weather-related defenses are raised.
Are field sobriety tests reliable during snow or rain?
No. Field tests lose reliability when performed on icy, wet, or sloped surfaces. Officers are supposed to consider conditions before conducting them. If they proceed anyway, the results can be challenged or excluded.
Can breath test results be affected by weather?
Not directly. However, indirect factors like mouth alcohol (from vomiting due to motion sickness or cold-induced nausea) or improper breath machine calibration can be relevant. An attorney should request maintenance records.
If I refused the breath test, can I still use weather as a defense?
Yes. In fact, without a chemical result, the state must rely even more heavily on officer observations—which are more vulnerable to challenge when bad weather provides another explanation.
Will the prosecutor drop my case just because of bad weather?
No. But a strong legal defense that incorporates weather data may convince the prosecution to offer a plea to a lesser charge or dismiss the case outright.
What kind of weather records can be used as evidence?
National Weather Service data, Chicago Department of Streets and Sanitation plow reports, live traffic cams, private weather station data, and even news footage may be admissible if authenticated properly.
Can I still win my DUI case even if I admitted to drinking?
Yes. Having alcohol in your system does not equal legal impairment. If your BAC was below the limit and your driving was explained by snow, ice, or fog, you may still beat the charge.
Where will my DUI case be heard if I was arrested in Chicago?
Most DUI cases in Chicago are heard at 26th and California (Leighton Criminal Courthouse) or at suburban locations like Skokie or Bridgeview, depending on the arresting agency.
How long do I have to fight a license suspension after a DUI arrest?
Only 30 days from the arrest date. Your DUI attorney must file a Petition to Rescind the Statutory Summary Suspension or your license will be suspended automatically—even before your criminal case ends.
Why You Should Hire The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg
Weather-related DUI arrests are more common than people think. But they are also beatable, with the right preparation. If you’re facing DUI charges in Chicago, Cook County, DuPage County, Will County, or Lake County, your best chance at avoiding a conviction is working with a defense lawyer who understands the impact of weather on evidence.
At The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg, I provide aggressive DUI defense backed by decades of courtroom experience. I know how to use environmental evidence, challenge field tests, and protect your license and record.
Your case is too important to leave to chance.
Call To Schedule A Free Consultation With The Law Offices Of David L. Freidberg
If you have been arrested for DUI in Chicago or anywhere in Illinois and want to know whether you can legally drive while your case is pending, contact The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg for immediate help. We provide free consultations 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
At The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg, I’ve spent my career defending good people in tough situations. I know the laws, the courts, and the defenses that work.
If you were arrested in Chicago, protect your future by contacting The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg. We have decades of experience handling DUI cases in Illinois. Our firm is available 24/7 to provide the legal defense you deserve.
Contact us today at (312) 560-7100 or toll-free at (800) 803-1442 for a free consultation. We’re available 24/7 to serve clients throughout Illinois, Cook County, DuPage County, Will County, and Lake County.