I Don’t Know What I Would
Have Done Without Him...
What Happens If I’m on Probation and Get a New DUI in Illinois?
Understanding the Stakes in Chicago, Illinois
Chicago is a city that never slows down, and neither does law enforcement. When you’re already
on probation and you’re arrested for a new DUI, your situation becomes extremely serious. The criminal justice system in Cook County takes probation violations and repeat offenses very seriously. I’ve defended many clients throughout Chicago, from neighborhoods like Wicker Park and Bridgeport to the South Loop and Lincoln Park, who suddenly found themselves facing the reality that one mistake while on probation can put their freedom at risk.
In Illinois, probation is meant to be a second chance—a way for a judge to let someone serve their sentence in the community rather than behind bars. However, that second chance can be revoked if you’re accused of committing a new crime, especially a DUI. Under Illinois law (730 ILCS 5/5-6-4), a probation violation can result in resentencing, jail, or prison. At the same time, you now face a brand-new case for driving under the influence under 625 ILCS 5/11-501, which carries its own serious penalties.
What makes this situation so complex is that you are now dealing with two separate but connected cases—a new DUI prosecution and a potential probation revocation proceeding. Each can affect the other, and the outcome depends heavily on how quickly you act and whether you have a skilled Chicago criminal defense lawyer representing you.
Illinois DUI Laws and the Difference Between Misdemeanor and Felony Charges
In most first-offense cases, a DUI in Illinois is classified as a Class A misdemeanor under 625 ILCS 5/11-501(c), punishable by up to one year in jail and fines of up to $2,500. However, certain factors automatically elevate a DUI to a felony, also known as Aggravated DUI. Examples include driving with a suspended license, causing injury or death, or having multiple prior DUIs. These are prosecuted under 625 ILCS 5/11-501(d) as Class 4 through Class X felonies, depending on the severity.
When you’re already on probation for another offense—whether it was theft, drug possession, or even a prior DUI—the court sees a new DUI as evidence that you violated the terms of probation. Even if your previous offense was non-violent or unrelated to alcohol, the court can revoke your probation simply because you’ve been arrested for a new offense.
In Cook County, probation officers are required to report any new arrests to the court immediately. That means you could have a probation violation hearing before your DUI case even begins. The prosecution does not have to prove the new DUI beyond a reasonable doubt to revoke your probation—they only need to show it’s more likely than not that you violated your terms. This lower burden of proof is what makes having an attorney so critical.
How the Criminal Process Unfolds After a DUI Arrest While on Probation
A DUI arrest in Chicago typically begins with a traffic stop or checkpoint. Law enforcement may pull you over for speeding, improper lane usage, or another infraction, and then conduct field sobriety tests or a breath test. If you refuse the breath test, Illinois’s implied consent law (625 ILCS 5/11-501.1) allows the state to suspend your driver’s license for up to one year.
Once you’re arrested, your fingerprints and information are sent to the Illinois State Police and your probation officer. This triggers a probation violation report, and your probation judge may issue a warrant for your arrest or schedule a violation hearing.
Meanwhile, your new DUI case begins in the Circuit Court of Cook County, typically at the Richard J. Daley Center or a suburban branch courthouse such as Rolling Meadows, Maywood, or Bridgeview. You’ll attend an arraignment, where the charges are read and you enter a plea. The court may impose stricter bond conditions or even revoke bond if the judge believes you pose a risk of reoffending.
During this period, you are balancing two legal battles—the probation case and the new DUI prosecution. Without proper coordination, statements or evidence from one case can damage your defense in the other. That’s why I always tell clients that the earlier you involve a defense attorney, the more opportunities we have to protect your rights and prevent further damage.
Realistic Example: A Chicago Case Study
A client from Logan Square came to my office after being arrested for DUI while on probation for a Class 4 felony drug possession case. Police alleged he ran a stop sign and showed signs of impairment. He refused the breath test, leading to an automatic license suspension and a probation violation notice.
In his case, our strategy was twofold. First, we challenged the legality of the traffic stop, arguing that the officer lacked a clear basis for the stop. Second, we focused on the probation hearing, emphasizing that no formal conviction existed for the new DUI and that the officer’s observations were unreliable without chemical evidence.
We presented testimony about his continued employment, completion of drug counseling, and clean record since being placed on probation. The judge allowed him to remain on probation, and eventually, the DUI charge was reduced to reckless driving through plea negotiations. The key was fighting both cases strategically and simultaneously.
What Evidence the State Will Try to Use Against You
In a Chicago DUI case, prosecutors rely on several categories of evidence. Police reports will describe your appearance, speech, and coordination. The state may introduce video footage from body cameras or squad cars, breath or blood test results, and witness statements. They can also subpoena probation records showing your conditions of supervision, including any alcohol restrictions.
In a probation violation hearing, the prosecutor can use any credible evidence, even if it wouldn’t be admissible in a criminal trial. This might include hearsay statements, reports from probation officers, or unverified lab results. For this reason, defense preparation is critical. I review every piece of evidence, challenge the reliability of testing devices, and demand full disclosure under Illinois Supreme Court Rule 415, which governs criminal discovery.
The state must prove its case, but when you’re on probation, the standard is lower, meaning we must be proactive in building reasonable doubt and demonstrating compliance.
Penalties and Collateral Consequences
If convicted of a DUI while on probation, you face both criminal and probationary penalties. The court could revoke your probation under 730 ILCS 5/5-6-4, resulting in the imposition of your original sentence—often jail or prison. On top of that, you face separate DUI penalties such as:
- Jail time or prison for aggravated DUI
- Mandatory alcohol evaluation and treatment
- Community service
- License suspension or revocation
- Vehicle impoundment
- Ignition interlock device requirements
- Permanent criminal record
Beyond the courtroom, a DUI conviction while on probation can affect employment, housing, professional licensing, and even future sentencing, as courts may treat you as a repeat offender. Insurance rates can skyrocket, and a second conviction may render you ineligible for court supervision under 730 ILCS 5/5-6-1.5, making the consequences even harsher.
How a Skilled Chicago Criminal Defense Lawyer Can Help
An experienced defense attorney is your greatest resource in this situation. I personally handle every aspect of both cases—from investigating the traffic stop and breath test procedures to defending against the probation revocation. Having handled DUI and probation cases for decades in Cook County, I understand how prosecutors build their cases and how judges weigh probation violations.
A defense lawyer can negotiate with prosecutors to coordinate both cases and sometimes delay probation hearings until the new DUI is resolved. We can also seek to modify probation rather than revoke it, presenting evidence of rehabilitation, employment, and community ties.
Most importantly, your lawyer ensures that your constitutional rights are protected throughout the process—especially your right to remain silent, your right against unreasonable searches under the Fourth Amendment, and your right to counsel.
Common Legal Defenses
Several legal defenses can apply when you’re accused of a DUI while on probation:
- Unlawful Traffic Stop: If the officer lacked probable cause, all evidence obtained may be suppressed.
- Invalid Field Sobriety Tests: These tests are subjective and can be affected by medical conditions, fatigue, or weather.
- Faulty Breath or Blood Tests: Breathalyzers must be properly calibrated and administered by certified operators.
- No Proof of Violation: For probation revocation, prosecutors must show credible evidence that you violated a condition.
- Mitigating Circumstances: Even if a violation occurred, the court can choose modification or reinstatement instead of revocation.
A defense attorney evaluates each element of the state’s case and develops a strategy tailored to your circumstances, emphasizing rehabilitation rather than punishment.
Qualities to Look for in a Chicago Criminal Defense Attorney
When your future is on the line, you need a lawyer who has a proven record in both DUI defense and probation violation cases. Look for someone who:
- Regularly practices in Cook County courts
- Understands Illinois criminal procedure and evidentiary rules
- Has trial experience and negotiation skills
- Maintains strong communication with clients
- Treats your case with urgency and discretion
A seasoned Chicago criminal defense lawyer will understand how local prosecutors and judges handle probation violation cases and can anticipate their approach to sentencing.
Questions to Ask in Your Consultation
During your free consultation, ask about your attorney’s courtroom experience, prior case outcomes, strategy for handling both the DUI and probation violation, and communication policies. Ask how evidence will be challenged, whether expert witnesses will be used, and what the potential outcomes are. Transparency and preparation are key indicators that your attorney is ready to fight for you.
Why You Need an Attorney and Why the Law Offices of David L. Freidberg Are the Right Choice
Facing a DUI while on probation is one of the most dangerous situations a defendant can experience. Without legal representation, you risk losing your freedom, your license, and your future. The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg have spent decades defending people throughout Chicago and the surrounding counties—Cook, DuPage, Will, and Lake.
Our firm offers 24/7 availability for emergencies, personalized defense strategies, and a history of success in reducing or dismissing charges. We handle every phase of your case, from the first appearance to trial and post-hearing advocacy. Don’t leave your fate in the hands of chance—the right attorney can change the outcome of your case.
When You Need a Fighter, Call Us!
If you were arrested in Chicago, protect your future by contacting The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg. We have decades of experience handling criminal, DUI, and traffic cases in Illinois. Our firm is available 24/7 to provide the legal defense you deserve.
Contact us today at (312) 560-7100 or toll-free at (800) 803-1442 for a free consultation. We’re available 24/7 to serve clients throughout Illinois, Cook County, DuPage County, Will County, and Lake County.